21 Paper Rejections Across My Master’s and Ph.D.: Keep Going

6 minute read

Published:

Academic homepages and CVs suffer from survivor bias: they only list papers after they cross the finish line. When you read someone’s publication list, you never see the early rejects, the Round 2 heartbreaks, or the revisions that still fell short.

I recently pulled my submission history from HotCRP and EasyChair. Looking at all the rejections stacked together told a much truer story of what doing systems and security research actually looks like.

Below is my log of 21 conference rejections (excluding withdrawals and unfinished drafts), grouped into my Master’s and Ph.D. research stages. Paper titles are intentionally omitted—which specific manuscript got rejected matters far less than recognizing how routine, repeated, and survivable rejection is.

Master’s Stage (5 Rejections)

These submissions come from research projects started during my Master’s studies (including my Master’s thesis project, whose final conference submission went out in 2021). Early on, aiming at top systems, security, and software engineering venues meant running straight into walls of Weak Reject and Strong Reject scores while learning how to frame a problem and build convincing evaluations.

YearVenueReview ScoresScore Meaning & ScaleRound / Outcome
2016FSE 20162 / 1 / 2 (avg 1.67)C / D / C on 1–4 (1 = D: Serious problems, will argue to reject, 2 = C: Weak paper, 3 = B, 4 = A)Rejected
2017ASPLOS 20172 / 2 / 3 (avg 2.33)2× Weak reject, 1× Weak accept (1–5 Overall merit: 1 Reject … 5 Strong accept)Rejected
2017ACM CCS 20173 / 2 / 2 (avg 2.33)1× Weak accept, 2× Weak reject (1–5 Overall merit: 1 Reject … 5 Strong accept)Rejected
2018ICSE 2018-1 / 1 / -2 (avg −0.67)Weak reject, Weak accept, Strong reject (−2 to +2 Overall evaluation: 0 Borderline)Rejected (with meta-review)
2021ASE 2021—Numerical scores hidden from authors (3 written reviews)Rejected (Master’s thesis project)

Ph.D. Stage (16 Rejections)

These submissions come from projects started during my Ph.D. (including follow-up submissions from Ph.D.-era projects in 2025–2026). Experience did not make rejections go away—it just unlocked every possible flavor of rejection: Early Reject, Round 1 Reject & Resubmit, Round 2 Reject, Major Revisions that still ended in rejection, and even a unanimous 1 / 1 / 1 years into my research career.

YearVenueReview ScoresScore Meaning & ScaleRound / Outcome
2019USENIX Security ‘19 (Winter)2 / 5 / 4 / 3 (avg 3.50)Reject & resubmit, Accept, Minor rev., Major rev. (1–5 Review rec.: 1 Reject … 5 Accept)Major Revision (not accepted in cycle)
2020USENIX Security ‘20 (Summer)2 / 4 / 4 / 2 (avg 3.00)2× Reject & resubmit, 2× Minor revision (1–5 Review rec.: 1 Reject … 5 Accept)Major Revision → Reject & Resubmit
2020ACM CCS 2020 (Cycle A)2 / 3 (avg 2.50)Weak reject, Neutral (1–5 Overall merit: 1 Reject, 3 Neutral, 5 Accept)Rejected (Round 1)
2021USENIX Security ‘21 (Winter)2 / 2 (avg 2.00)2× Reject & resubmit (1–6 Review rec.); Overall merit: Top 50% but not top 25%Round 1 Reject & Resubmit
2022NDSS 2022 (Summer)2 / 3 / 2 / 3 / 4 (avg 2.80)2× Leaning reject, 2× Major rev., 1× Minor rev. (1–5 Overall rec.: 5 Accept)Rejected
2022ACM CCS 2022 (Cycle B)3 / 4 / 2 (avg 3.00)Neutral, Weak accept, Weak reject (1–6 Overall merit: 3 Neutral, 4 Weak accept)Rejected
2023USENIX Security ‘23 (Winter)3 / 3 / 4 / 3 / 4 (avg 3.40)3× Accept cond. on major rev., 2× Reject (1–4 Rec. decision, lower is better: 1 Accept, 4 Reject)Round 2 Reject
2023ACM CCS 2023 (Cycle B)3 / 3 / 2 (avg 2.67)2× Neutral, 1× Weak reject (1–5 Overall merit: 3 Neutral, 4 Weak accept)Round 2 Reject
2024NDSS 2024 (Fall)2 / 2 (avg 2.00)2× Weak reject (1–5 Overall rec.: 1 Reject … 5 Strong accept)Early Rejected
2024ICSE 20242 / 3 / 3 (avg 2.67)1× Weak reject, 2× Weak accept (1–5 Overall merit: 1 Reject … 5 Strong accept)Rejected
2024SIGCOMM 20242 / 2 / 3 (avg 2.33)2× Weak reject, 1× Weak accept (1–5 Overall merit: 1 Reject … 5 Strong accept)Rejected
2024OOPSLA 20243 / 2 / 2 (avg 2.33)1× Weak reject, 2× Reject (1–6 Overall merit: 3 Weak reject, 4 Weak accept)Rejected
2025USENIX Security ‘25 (Cycle 1)—Numerical scores hidden from authors (written reviews only)Rejected
2025ASE 20252 / 2 / 2 (avg 2.00)3× Weak reject (1–5 Overall merit); Reviewer D rec. = 1 (Reject)Rejected
2026MSR 20261 / 1 / 1 (avg 1.00)3× Reject (1–5 Overall merit: 1 Reject … 5 Award-quality accept)Rejected
2026ISSTA 20263 / 2 / 2 (avg 2.33)1× Weak accept, 2× Weak reject (1–5 Overall merit); Major-Revision round Reviewer D = 1 (Reject on 1–3)Rejected (Major-Revision round)

Why I Keep This List: Don’t Give Up

A few things stand out to me whenever I re-read these rows:

  1. Close doesn’t guarantee an accept—and harsh doesn’t mean hopeless. Early in my Ph.D., a submission drew an Accept (5) and Minor revision (4), went through Major Revision twice across back-to-back cycles, and still came back Reject & Resubmit. Years later, another project walked into 2 / 2 / 2, then 1 / 1 / 1, then a Major-Revision round rejection before finally finding its home.
  2. Rejections don’t stop when you “get better.” Notice the dates: there are just as many rejections in 2023–2026 as in 2016–2020. Pushing into harder problems or unfamiliar communities naturally resets the scoreboard.
  3. Every row above forced the work to grow. Peer review is noisy, and every researcher has stories of frustrating reviews. Yet almost every painful rejection in these two tables exposed a real blind spot—an unstated assumption, a fragile baseline, a missing experiment, or a muddled story—that, once fixed, turned a borderline draft into solid work I could stand behind for years.

A rejection notification is a verdict on one version of a manuscript on one deadline—not a verdict on the core idea, and never a verdict on you.

If you are a graduate student staring at HotCRP or EasyChair tonight—whether it is your very first reject, a 1 / 1 / 1 that stings, or a Major Revision that still didn’t make it—close the tab for a day, take what is useful from the reviews, rebuild what is weak, and send it out again. Don’t give up.